KaelySilver Gel Eyeliner Pencil,Waterproof Smudge Proof Eye Liner Pen,Cat Eye Goth Halloween Makeup,Eye Black Face Paint Lipstick Crayon,Color Colorful Eyeliner Eyeshadow Stick,01

This is not long lasting wear, it does smudge. Not the one I was looking for, will not buy again.

I loved how easy this eyeliner is to apply and work with, especially if you want a cat eye or a smoky eye. To get all 4 colors for $9.99 was the best deal. I use a brush underneath my lashes to get more of a smoky eye look and it works great. I'm very happy with my purchase and the variety of the colors.

Always down to try new products. This one is one of those multi company same crappy product scam. Only recieved one when I bought the 2 pack. Tried to return but Amazon kept showing an image of a different item I bought to return. So there's that. Not worth the call so I guess I'm eating 9$. Could be worse. So continuing, Multiple companies with the same product with all the same one star and two star reviews that are all the same and all happen to be right this time. Beware of those companies. I tried it, smudge right off. I tried caking it on. First just tried to get a good base, I felt like I was using a dryed out white board marker going over and over and over just trying to get something stick and make it black enough. Now I have a nub of eyeliner left. Let it sit for a few minutes. I touch my eye lid with my finger tips and it came right off. It's like trying to use a black crayon on your eye lids and expecting it to stick.....Good Luck. Going straight into the garbage.

So I LOOOVVEEE the deep color and how easily it glides on,but It definitely smudges and gives you raccoon eyes if you’re out and about on a hot day, or have naturally oily skin. Also the way it holds I didn’t trust trying to do a winged liner looked but maybe with a liner brush just rub some on? But that’s why I’m crossed because was really hoping it would stay on without the raccoon look after. Will try it when it gets cooler out and see how it holds then because like I said it gloves on beautifully and the comfort is so rich it made my eyes pop

All four are of different quality. One is soft, the other is hard, and the third and fourth wear out immediately.

This is not your average eyeliner. I have been searching for a long time for the best eyeliner but always had to settle for something that just didn’t do the job. Then I found AYKY Smooth Gel Eyeliner. OMG I put it on and it was love at first sight. The packaging got my attention then I put it on and it just was so smooth and it was so easy. I was so impressed. I am a customer for life.

The Blue is not as intense as the black. But, I Couldnt get out. So, this was the next best thing. Love the It goes on easily and has a cute top to protect if you place it in your purse. No sharpener required.

Very good pigmentation but it smears under the eye. Is not water proof